Blue Buffalo review: grade C (65/100)

Grade C, 65 out of 100, ranked 9th of 9 dry dog foods and 10th of 10 grain-free foods we graded. Owners give it 4.6 stars on PetSmart, and it names a PhD nutrition scientist.

A Boston terrier with a purple collar on a dining chair

C

65 out of 100

Dry dog food (kibble)

Blue Buffalo at a glance

Blue Buffalo started in Wilton, Connecticut, and General Mills bought it in 2018. Its lines include Life Protection Formula and the Wilderness line, which has grain-free recipes. We graded BLUE Life Protection Formula Adult Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe. In our dry dog food rankings it scores 65 (C) and ranks ninth of nine.

Category

Score

Recall record

16.8 / 30

Nutrition standards

20.4 / 30

Owner ratings

17.9 / 30

Storage

10 / 10

Total

65 / 100 (C)

Nutrition standards

  • Nutritionist named publicly: Matt Panasevich, PhD in nutritional sciences, is a senior nutrition scientist in Blue Buffalo’s pet nutrition R&D group.

  • AAFCO statement: yes. Life Protection Chicken & Brown Rice is formulated to meet AAFCO nutrient profiles for adult maintenance.

  • Where it’s made and how it’s tested: Blue Buffalo names two manufacturing facilities, in Joplin, Missouri, and Richmond, Indiana. It says suppliers test every incoming shipment, ingredients are rechecked before entering the plants, packaged food passes metal detection and X-ray, and finished food is tested on site or by a third-party lab before release.

  • Research: a 2024 Journal of Animal Science study, with a Blue Buffalo co-author, tested the company’s Natural Veterinary Diet GI Low-Fat food in adult dogs.

What owners say

Life Protection Chicken & Brown Rice has 4.6 stars from 3,911 reviews on PetSmart. Our owner-ratings score is based on Blue Buffalo’s Trustpilot profile, which our method places near a neutral 3.5 stars.

Details

Detail

What we found

Recipe graded

Life Protection Formula Adult Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe

Grain-free options

Wilderness Adult Chicken Grain-Free and Wilderness Adult Salmon Grain-Free (dry)

Calories

3,633 kcal/kg, 379 kcal per cup

Storage

Dry, shelf-stable

Price

30 lb: $67.98 at PetSmart

Maker

Blue Buffalo, a General Mills company

Checked November 19, 2026.

Questions

Is Blue Buffalo a good dog food?

Blue Buffalo scores 65 out of 100 (C). Its Life Protection Chicken & Brown Rice recipe has 4.6 stars from 3,911 PetSmart reviews, and a PhD nutrition scientist works on its formulas.

Is Blue Buffalo Wilderness grain-free?

Many Wilderness recipes are, including Adult Chicken Grain-Free and Adult Salmon Grain-Free dry foods. The Wilderness line also includes recipes with oats, barley, or brown rice, so check the bag for the words “Grain-Free.” See our grain-free rankings.

How do Blue Buffalo and Purina ONE differ?

Both have well-rated adult chicken recipes on PetSmart: Blue Buffalo Life Protection has 4.6 stars from 3,911 reviews and Purina ONE Chicken & Rice has 4.8 stars from 6,731. Blue Buffalo names its two plants and a PhD nutrition scientist. Purina ONE’s recipe is backed by an AAFCO feeding trial. See Purina ONE.

Rankings this brand appears in

Dog Food Notes

Grades are general information about pet food, not veterinary advice. Ask your veterinarian before changing your dog’s diet, especially if your dog has a health condition.