DOG FOOD, GRADED
Straight answers about what goes in your dog’s bowl.
We grade 18 dog food brands out of 100 with one method: recall record, nutrition standards, owner ratings, and storage. Rankings cover air-dried, dry, grain-free, and subscription food, from Purina and Hill’s to Spot & Tango and Nom Nom.

Category rankings
Best dry dog food 2026: 9 brands graded
Nine dry, shelf-stable dog foods scored on recall record, nutrition standards, owner ratings, and storage. Purina ONE leads at 96; Hill's Science Diet and Spot & Tango UnKibble follow.
Best grain-free dog food 2026: 10 foods graded
Ten brands that sell grain-free dog food, ranked by each brand's overall grade. Purina ONE's True Instinct line leads at 96; Hill's Science Diet and Spot & Tango UnKibble follow.
Best subscription dog food 2026: 6 brands graded
Six dog foods sold by subscription, scored on recall record, nutrition standards, owner ratings, and storage. Nom Nom leads at 86; Spot & Tango UnKibble and The Farmer's Dog follow.
Best air-dried dog food 2026: 6 brands graded
Six shelf-stable dried dog foods scored on recall record, nutrition standards, owner ratings, and storage. Spot & Tango UnKibble leads at 81; Open Farm and Sundays follow.
Top-graded brands
A
Purina ONE review: grade A (96/100)
Grade A, 96 out of 100, ranked 1st of 9 dry dog foods we graded. It has 4.8 stars from 6,731 PetSmart reviews, and its Chicken & Rice Formula is backed by an AAFCO feeding trial.
96/100
A
Nom Nom review: grade A (86/100)
Grade A, 86 out of 100, ranked 1st of 6 subscription foods we graded. It names a board-certified veterinary nutritionist, makes its food in its own Nashville kitchens, and has 4.4 stars from 1,871 Trustpilot reviews.
86/100
B
Hill's Science Diet review: grade B (81/100)
Grade B, 81 out of 100, ranked 2nd of 9 dry dog foods we graded. Its adult recipe is backed by an AAFCO feeding trial, and Hill's makes its dry food in its own US plants.
81/100
B
Spot & Tango UnKibble review: grade B (81/100)
Grade B, 81 out of 100, ranked 1st of 6 air-dried foods we graded. It has 4.6 stars from 2,908 Trustpilot reviews, and Spot & Tango says it makes UnKibble in its own Pennsylvania facility.
81/100
B
The Farmer's Dog review: grade B (80/100)
Grade B, 80 out of 100, ranked 3rd of 6 subscription foods we graded. It names three board-certified veterinary nutritionists and funds peer-reviewed research on fresh food.
80/100
B
Royal Canin review: grade B (79/100)
Grade B, 79 out of 100, ranked 4th of 9 dry dog foods we graded. It has 4.1 stars from 7,707 Trustpilot reviews and no dog food recalls found since 2016.
79/100
B
Open Farm Air Dried review: grade B (76/100)
Grade B, 76 out of 100, ranked 2nd of 6 air-dried foods we graded. It leads on nutrition standards, with a named board-certified veterinary nutritionist and test-and-hold safety testing.
76/100
B
Purina Pro Plan review: grade B (76/100)
Grade B, 76 out of 100, ranked 5th of 9 dry dog foods we graded. It has 4.5 stars from 9,293 PetSmart reviews and a 27.6 of 30 nutrition standards score.
76/100
Head to head
Badlands Ranch vs Sundays: which air-dried dog food scores higher?
Sundays scores 74 and Badlands Ranch 70. Owners rate both well; Sundays details its safety testing and covers all life stages, and Badlands Ranch has more reviews and a lower cost per calorie.
Open Farm vs Sundays for Dogs: which air-dried food scores higher?
Open Farm scores 76 and Sundays 74. Open Farm names a board-certified nutritionist; Sundays leads on owner ratings.
The Real Meat Company vs ZIWI Peak: air-dried dog food compared
ZIWI Peak scores 68 and The Real Meat Company 67. ZIWI makes its food in its own kitchens; Real Meat is the cheaper of the two per calorie.
Sundays vs ZIWI Peak: which air-dried dog food scores higher?
Sundays scores 74 and ZIWI Peak 68. Sundays leads on owner ratings and details its lot testing; ZIWI makes its food in its own New Zealand kitchens.



Guides
Air-dried dog food, explained
How air-drying works, how it compares with kibble, freeze-dried, and fresh food, and why the small portions are easy to overfeed.
How to feed your dog well on a budget
Price and nutrition aren't the same thing. How to compare dog foods by cost per calorie, what "complete and balanced" guarantees, and the cheaper ways to add fresh food.
Fresh dog food vs. kibble: what the research shows
Fresh food tested as more digestible than kibble in two short studies. Neither showed a health benefit. Here's what the evidence supports and what fresh food costs you in money and freezer space.
How to check if your dog food has been recalled
Where to look up recalls, how to match your bag's lot code, the usual reasons food gets pulled, and how to report a problem.