Fresh dog food vs. kibble: what the research shows
Fresh food tested as more digestible than kibble in two short studies. Neither showed a health benefit. Here's what the evidence supports and what fresh food costs you in money and freezer space.

The short version
In two University of Illinois feeding studies, fresh and human-grade cooked diets were more digestible than the kibble they were tested against, and dogs produced less stool.
Both studies were small and short. Neither measured long-term health outcomes.
A Tufts veterinary nutritionist says there’s little evidence that any one format is better for an average healthy dog.
Fresh food cost four to six times the most expensive dry food in a 2022 Tufts price comparison, and most fresh plans need freezer and fridge space.
Is fresh dog food better than kibble?
It’s more digestible in the studies done so far. Whether it’s better for your dog’s health hasn’t been shown. Kibble is made by extrusion, a fast high-heat, high-pressure cooking process and the most common way pet food is made worldwide. Fresh foods are cooked more gently and keep far more water, so they’re sold refrigerated or frozen.
What the digestibility studies found
Study | Diets compared | Main result | Funded by |
|---|---|---|---|
Do et al., 2021 (Journal of Animal Science) | One kibble, one fresh roasted diet, two human-grade cooked diets; 12 beagles | Dry matter digestibility 81.5% for the kibble, 87.1% for the fresh diet, about 90.8% for the human-grade diets. Stool output fell from 95.9 g a day on kibble to 39 to 64 g on the others. | JustFoodForDogs |
Algya et al., 2018 (Journal of Animal Science) | One kibble, two roasted refrigerated diets, one raw diet; 8 beagles | Protein digestibility 85.1% for the kibble, 92.0% to 94.6% for the refrigerated diets | Freshpet |
Diet also changed the dogs’ gut bacteria in both studies. Neither study tied those shifts to a health benefit.
What the studies don’t show
No health outcome. Blood values stayed mostly within normal ranges on every diet. The Do et al. authors say long-term benefits still need testing.
Small and short. Eight or 12 beagles of one breed, fed each diet for 28 days.
One product per format. Each study compared specific products, so the results don’t cover every kibble or every fresh food.
Dr. Cailin Heinze, a Tufts veterinary nutritionist, wrote in 2022 that there are minimal scientific data showing fresh food or any other diet type benefits an average healthy dog more than a good complete and balanced kibble.
The practical trade-offs
| Kibble | Fresh (refrigerated or frozen) |
|---|---|---|
Cost | Lowest per day | 4 to 6 times the most expensive kibble (Tufts, 2022) |
Storage | Room temperature; use an open bag within 2 to 3 months | Freezer and fridge space; frozen packs need time to thaw |
Calories per cup | About 300 to over 700 | Often under 200, so the bowl is fuller |
Moisture | About 10% | 75% to 80% or more |
A fresh diet’s high water content means larger portions, which some dogs like and some struggle to finish. A calorie-dense kibble is easy to overfeed.
Is there a middle option?
Yes. Shelf-stable dried whole-food diets sit between the two: gently processed like fresh food, stored like kibble. Air-dried and dehydrated foods such as ZIWI Peak and Spot & Tango’s UnKibble fall into this group. We found no published study testing the digestibility of air-dried dog food specifically, so the fresh-food studies above don’t automatically apply. See air-dried dog food, explained and our air-dried dog food grades.
Questions
Do vets recommend fresh dog food?
WSAVA’s guidance for owners doesn’t rank formats. It asks whether a food is complete and balanced and whether the company employs a qualified nutritionist. See WSAVA’s questions for pet food companies.
Why does my dog poop less on fresh food?
Both Illinois studies measured less stool on the fresh and human-grade diets, which fits with higher digestibility: more of the food is absorbed.
Can I mix fresh food and kibble?
Yes. If the fresh food is complete and balanced, cut the kibble so total daily calories stay the same. If it isn’t, keep it to 10% of calories or less.