WSAVA guidelines for choosing dog food, explained

The four questions WSAVA tells owners to ask a pet food company, what a good answer looks like, and where to look the answers up.

A man holding a small dog in a room

The short version

  • WSAVA’s Global Nutrition Committee guideline, updated in March 2021, tells owners to ask a pet food company four questions: who its nutritionist is, who formulates the food, how it checks quality, and what research it has published.

  • WSAVA counts a nutritionist as qualified with a PhD in animal nutrition or board certification in veterinary nutrition (ACVN, whose diplomates now sign as DACVIM (Nutrition), or ECVCN).

  • The Pet Nutrition Alliance’s 2023 Pet Food Manufacturer Evaluation Report lists how 243 companies answered a shorter version of these questions.

  • If a company can’t or won’t answer, WSAVA’s advice is to be cautious.

What the WSAVA guidelines are

The World Small Animal Veterinary Association (WSAVA) publishes a short guide to selecting pet food, last updated on March 10, 2021. It lists questions to put to the company, because most of what separates one food from another isn’t printed on the bag, and it names no brands.

The four questions to ask a pet food company

1. Do you employ a qualified nutritionist?

WSAVA’s bar is a PhD in animal nutrition, or board certification from the American College of Veterinary Nutrition (ACVN) or the European College of Veterinary Comparative Nutrition (ECVCN). The ACVN specialty now sits inside the American College of Veterinary Internal Medicine, so the same credential also appears as DACVIM (Nutrition). WSAVA suggests asking for the person’s name and whether they’re on staff, since a consultant may have less say over recipes than an employee.

2. Who formulates the food?

The answers WSAVA lists run from an experienced formulator with an MS or PhD in animal nutrition, to a veterinarian, to a pet owner, breeder, or trainer. WSAVA notes that diet formulation isn’t part of standard veterinary school training, so a general-practice vet’s name on a food tells you less than a nutritionist’s.

3. What quality control do you run?

Ask whether the food meets AAFCO nutrient profiles by calculation from a nutrient database or by lab analysis of the finished product. WSAVA’s quality checklist covers ingredient testing, final nutrient analysis, toxins, bacteria, and packaging and shelf life. A company should be able to give an average or typical value for every essential nutrient.

4. What research have you published?

WSAVA asks whether the company has run feeding studies or nutrition research and published them in peer-reviewed journals. Companies aren’t required to do research to sell a food, so many have none to point to.

What to check on the label

WSAVA lists four label checks:

  1. A nutritional adequacy statement that says “complete” for your dog’s life stage.

  2. Calories per gram or per serving.

  3. Direct contact details for the company, such as a phone number or email.

  4. Who makes the food: “Made by” tells you more than “Made for” or “Distributed by.”

Foods labeled for “short-term,” “intermittent,” or “complementary” feeding should make up 10% or less of the diet.

Where to find the answers

Most of this isn’t on the label, which is why the Pet Nutrition Alliance (PNA) built its “Dare to Ask” tool. The current edition, the 2023 Pet Food Manufacturer Evaluation Report, covers 243 manufacturers and asks three questions: whether the company employs or uses a nutrition expert, whether it owns its plants, and the level of one randomly chosen nutrient per 1,000 kcal. The answers were collected from June to November 2022, so a company’s setup may have changed since. Companies that didn’t answer are listed as “Did not respond” or “Declined to respond.”

How Dog Food Notes uses these questions

Our nutrition standards score, worth 30 of 100 points, follows WSAVA’s questions. We use what each brand states publicly plus its PNA answers, and we link every input. See how we grade for the point breakdown.

Among the six air-dried foods we grade, Open Farm names a board-certified veterinary nutritionist (Dr. Moran Tal-Gavriel, Dip. ECVCN). Sundays says board-certified nutritionists help formulate its food. Spot & Tango says its food is formulated with veterinary and animal nutritionists and names two veterinary advisors. The full scores are in our air-dried dog food grades.

Questions

Is the WSAVA list a ranking of dog food brands?

No. WSAVA doesn’t endorse or rank brands. The Pet Nutrition Alliance publishes how companies answered its version of the questions.

Does a food need a board-certified nutritionist to be safe?

No. A food without one can still meet AAFCO nutrient profiles. The questions are a screen: a named, qualified nutritionist and published quality control give you more evidence that the food is formulated and made carefully.

What does “Did not respond” mean in the PNA report?

It means the company didn’t answer the survey, so the report tells you nothing about that company either way. WSAVA’s general advice is to be cautious when a company can’t or won’t answer these questions.

Is DACVN the same as DACVIM (Nutrition)?

Yes. Both refer to a board-certified veterinary nutritionist in the US. The specialty moved under the American College of Veterinary Internal Medicine, so newer bios use DACVIM (Nutrition).

Dog Food Notes

Grades are general information about pet food, not veterinary advice. Ask your veterinarian before changing your dog’s diet, especially if your dog has a health condition.