How we grade dog food

Every food is scored out of 100 on the same four things, from public sources we link. Here’s exactly how the points work.

The short version

We score each dog food out of 100:

Category

Points

What it measures

Recall record

30

Dog food recalls since 2016, weighted by how serious and how recent

Nutrition standards

30

Questions WSAVA tells owners to ask a pet food company

Owner ratings

30

Public owner reviews, adjusted for how many there are

Storage

10

Whether the food is shelf-stable, refrigerated, or frozen

We round the total to the nearest whole point, then grade it: A is 85 or more, B is 75 to 84, C is 65 to 74, D is 55 to 64, and F is below 55. Every food is scored on the same scale. Our grade tables list foods by category, so an air-dried food is ranked against other air-dried foods.

Recall record (30 points)

Every food starts with full marks. We take points off for each recall of the brand’s dog food since 2016:

Recall type

Within the last five years

Older than five years

Serious: bacteria such as Salmonella or Listeria, toxins such as aflatoxin, or too much or too little of a nutrient

minus 9.6

minus 4.8

Other: foreign material such as metal or plastic, labeling

minus 3.6

minus 1.8

The recall score can’t go below zero.

We check the FDA’s recall records, company notices, and Dog Food Advisor’s and Petful’s recall histories. The FDA’s public recall data is thin before 2023, so a brand with no recall found may still have an older one we couldn’t see. Our recall guide explains how to check a food yourself.

Nutrition standards (30 points)

These points follow the questions in the WSAVA guideline for selecting pet food. We use what each company states publicly and its answers in the Pet Nutrition Alliance’s 2023 report.

What we check

Points

A qualified nutritionist named publicly (PhD in animal nutrition, or board-certified: DACVIM Nutrition, DACVN, or Dip. ECVCN)

8.4

An AAFCO “complete and balanced” statement for at least one life stage

6

At least one recipe backed by an AAFCO feeding trial

3.6

The company names the plant or its own kitchens where the food is made, and describes how finished food is tested (both: 6; one: 3.6)

6

Peer-reviewed research on the company’s own food

6

A company that doesn’t publish an answer gets no points for that question, even if its real answer would be a good one. You can always ask the company directly.

Owner ratings (30 points)

We use the brand’s Trustpilot rating. Where a brand has no Trustpilot profile, we use the largest retailer rating we could open and say which one. Small samples are pulled toward a neutral 3.5 stars: we average the brand’s rating with 200 imaginary reviews at 3.5 stars, so a 5-star average from 20 reviews doesn’t outscore a 4.6 from thousands. On that adjusted rating, 1 star scores 0 and 5 stars score 30, in a straight line.

Storage (10 points)

Shelf-stable food scores 10, refrigerated food 7, and frozen food 5. Frozen food needs freezer space and time to thaw, and refrigerated food has a short life once opened.

What we don’t score

  • Price: published prices aren’t comparable across subscription and retail brands, so price doesn’t affect the score. We list the prices we checked, with the date, and the cost per 1,000 kcal where we can work it out.

  • Ingredients and taste: we note main ingredients, but we don’t score “better” ingredients, which is where most marketing lives.

  • Brand statistics: digestibility and satisfaction figures from a company are reported as the company’s claims and don’t affect the score.

Rules we follow

  • Every brand is scored with this same method. See About.

  • Every score input links to its source on the brand’s page, with the date we checked it.

  • When a brand publishes new information, such as naming a nutritionist or publishing research, we rescore it.

  • Grades are general information, not veterinary advice.

Dog Food Notes

Grades are general information about pet food, not veterinary advice. Ask your veterinarian before changing your dog’s diet, especially if your dog has a health condition.